Target-date funds were built on a single promise: one investment decision at enrolment, and the fund handles the rest as retirement approaches. In a roundtable discussion, experts from SLGI Asset Management Inc. and Fidelity Canada Institutional examined whether that promise still holds, and what it takes to keep it as the retirement landscape continues to shift.
Retirement itself has changed. Canadians live longer, save at different rates, and leave the workforce in less predictable ways. Glide paths have had to follow. Chhad Aul, chief investment officer and head of multi-asset solutions at SLGI Asset Management Inc., says, "The big evolution over the years has focused much more around specific outcomes that we can actually summarize and measure." Volatility metrics alone no longer tell the full story. The Canadian Association of Pension Supervisory Authorities has moved toward outcome-focused rules, and that shift has pushed managers to model income replacement directly into glide path design. The result is a generation of funds built around what members actually need at retirement rather than what markets historically delivered.
Income replacement ratios have become the industry's central benchmark. Farzan Qureshi, who leads institutional business development at Sun Life Global Investments, says, "It's having those real quantitative metrics that you can measure against that delivers across retirement outcomes." SLGI now models closer to 60 percent of pre-retirement income as the right target for most Canadian workers, down from the 70 percent standard once widely used. Jon Knowles, institutional portfolio manager in Global Asset Allocation at Fidelity Investments, adds that persona-based modelling, covering members who save a lot, save little, or joined at different stages, shows what outcomes actually mean for individuals rather than averages. A single average conceals wide variation in member experience.
Sequence-of-returns risk is the danger that poor market returns early in retirement, or in the years leading up to it, undermine the sustainability of retirement income. It remains one of the more underweighted concerns in target-date design. Stéphanie Mariamo, vice president of institutional business development at Fidelity Canada Institutional, says, "We feel that sequence risk is being framed through too narrow a lens." The demographics support her concern. Roughly a third of plan members retire before 65 and a third after age 69. A growing share drift in and out of the workforce rather than stopping cleanly. Aul calls it the central design trade-off: "There's a lot of science in glide path design, but there's a lot of art as well, and a lot of that art comes down to the trade-off between accumulated assets and sequence risk."
Both designs target the same goal: helping members retire with enough assets while managing the risks they face. SLGI's view is that protecting members when sequence risk is highest takes priority. Aul says, "We come back to this debate internally every couple of years." Each time, the team arrives at the same conclusion: reducing portfolio risk by the retirement date offers the best balance between accumulation and protection at the point of greatest vulnerability. Fidelity's 2026 research, authored by Bruno Weinberg Crocco, Knowles, and Darren Zeng, found that a through glide path produced greater wealth at age 65 in 74 percent of simulated environments. Mariamo notes that 85 percent of US target-date assets sit in through-retirement designs. "In our view, retirement is not the finishing line. There can still be another 20, 30 years, if not more," she says.
Illiquid assets are now embedded in glide path design. A static portfolio, stress-tested across decades of retirement scenarios, holds close to 20 percent in illiquid assets near retirement, built to add return and provide downside protection. Aul is direct about how alternatives should be chosen: "It's really important not to think of alts as some kind of homogeneous group that all deliver the same characteristics to the portfolio." Quality private fixed income helps reduce duration exposure while capturing a liquidity premium. Real assets, spanning real estate, infrastructure, and commodities, offer inflation protection and a smoother return profile. Liquidity management matters here. Knowles points out that "the underlying [investor] here is an individual shareholder that needs and wants and requires daily liquidity," a demand profile that differs from the lumpy redemptions institutional managers typically handle.
The answer depends on the market. Knowles says Fidelity favours passive strategies in highly efficient markets, citing Canadian real return bonds, while focusing active management in US equities, where Fidelity has added value even in difficult conditions. Qureshi points out that passive investing's recent outperformance came during an extended bull market dominated by a small number of large-cap stocks. Conditions may not persist. Knowles also warns against allowing cost to dominate the design discussion, flagging "the over-emphasis on lowest cost being the best solution." Fees should be weighed against the investment capabilities and retirement outcomes a strategy is built to deliver. The most efficient fund is the one that meets member income targets, not simply the cheapest one on the shelf.
Two directions are in view: guaranteed income and personalization. Qureshi sees merit in guaranteed income inside a target-date structure, though the US experience shows adoption has been slow because of cost and liquidity trade-offs. "That's a really interesting one that the industry might want to solve in a slightly different way than a typical annuity," he says. Personalization, drawing on each member's savings rate, retirement timing, and account balance, is attracting attention. The operational challenge is delivering individualized portfolios to thousands of members at scale without losing the simplicity that made target-date funds work. Mariamo offers the clearest caution: "This is not a topic of interest for every plan member." Sophistication only has value if members stay invested. Plan sponsors and advisers can explore further analysis across these themes through premium research and reports.